An Open Letter to the Devout Brazilian Roman Catholic Surfers of the WCT

Hey guys,

Much as I appreciate the shout outs in your post-heat interviews and Instagram posts, it’s time to stop invoking My name and giving Me credit for your competitive success. 

First of all, just like every other human that’s ever been on this planet, and any of the thousand or so religions that have been cooked up, you’ve got the whole God thing spectacularly wrong. Every version of Me you’ve dreamed up is pure speculation, every creed, book or scripture written merely a mirror of the time and place they’re written, and doesn’t stand up to any objective measure.

The big fella (God's family archives)

Don’t get me wrong, cocksure globetrotting wave-rider, there’s some top advice in those books, we’re all fans of the decency, love, and forgiveness parts of the Bible and the Quran etc, but there’s no secret, exclusive moral code contained within that can’t be practiced using your basic, garden-variety, secular common sense – treating others how you’d like them to treat you, etc. It’s not rocket science.

And, seriously, there’s some bollocks – supposedly the Word of Me – in these page turners that hasn’t aged well. Whoever wrote the books of Leviticus and Deuteronomy had some issues best sorted out with a psychologist, rather than turned into revenge porn. Just for the record, I NEVER told anyone to cut off unfaithful wives’ hands (Deuteronomy 25:11-12) or said I’d force parents to eat their own children as punishment for not listening to me (Leviticus 26:27-30). 

What do you take me for? A psychopath? 

Believe me when I say, well-to-do master of air and rail game, I told no-one anything of the sort. There are hundreds of such nonsenses I was supposed to have dictated to people over the 1500 years the Bible was cobbled together, but it was all imagined! Yarns repeated often and solemnly enough in a superstitious world to become real. (And yes I’m sticking to the Bible here, ’cos that’s the Supernatural Deity belief system you were born into.)

Look, there may WELL be a Me who conjures and weaves the universe into and out of existence, perhaps I simply AM existence, or the universe, but if there is such a Thing as Me, I bear bugger-all resemblance to any of your (quite frankly hilarious) personifications and imaginings so far. 

But I get it, young Latino Firebrand with sticker-laden surfboard, much religious faith comes from perfectly understandable human traits, many of them very sweet. We love our family and friends, the grief we feel when they die is so sharp and painful that we wishful-think heaven into existence, so we can be consoled by imagining a heavenly reunion one day. And certainly, the idea of an afterlife makes it easier for us to contemplate that fearful day we too become a corpse. And so, smart cookies all through human history looking for power and social control have levered these two emotions – love and fear – into different versions of the same fantastic story – do the right thing and the reward of eternal life is yours, misbehave, or be born into a heathen society, and hellfire awaits. I won’t point out the resemblance that such a hell carries with the earthbound volcanic lava that inspired its imagining. And let’s not get started on the idiocy of different subsets of the same supposed faith turning on each other. (Could anything more sharply betray the human origins of religion? FFS)

I want to be clear, oh impressively lithe, bilingual athlete, I’m not against believing in things greater than yourself – in this broad respect, you’re very much on the money – and I’m actually very fond of you, despite your total self-absorption (and you Me-botherers certainly don’t have a monopoly on THAT little trait on tour). 

So, for your sake and Mine, let’s stop for a moment and think, together, about what you’re actually saying when you give Me credit for, say, answering your prayers and sending you a heat-winning wave.

First of all. You’re fond of attesting to the power of prayer. It can produce miracles! Infinite Glory! Yes? Yes! You are also, presumably, not oblivious to all the messed-up crap out there. You’re aware of the 80 million people in the world right now who’ve been forced to flee their homes, 25 million of which are refugees. People trapped in lives of misery, boredom and danger, whose various prayers to various Gods (humbly asking just to be able to live at home or whatever) are seemingly not being answered as yours are. What are they doing wrong with this prayer malarkey that you seem to be doing so right? Has your virtuosity on a wave somehow magnified your virtue of prayer, and mysteriously unlocked a clear line of comms to the Divine?

You might argue that giving Me shout outs on Insta and post heat pressers is your way of demonstrating humility, but this is not the case, my tattooed, product-endorsing influencer friend, what it actually says is that you believe you deserve special favour. It makes you look like a Total Cock.

And it makes ME look like a Total Cock, too. Like I’m part of your competitive arsenal, some kind of secret weapon to unleash in clutch moments. To be prayed to as part of the pre-heat routine, acknowledged post-victory, briefly forgotten in a board-smashing post-defeat fury. 

The best parts of religion and secular spiritualism are about getting over yourself. Serving others, humility. I won’t have My name attached to this myopic parade. So, stop it. Please.

Religion worked well when humanity was starting to ask questions and figure stuff out. It was understandable that gods were conjured to make sense of floods and famines, natural phenomena, locusts and loss. It was – and still can be – a good set of training wheels for decency and charity.

Dear talented, hardworking, fortunate athlete. You’re not at all a bad person. You’re great! You mean well, and of course you’re welcome to reach out to Me any time. But let’s keep those convos humble, and between us. 

Oh, and it’ll serve you well to pray for something other than competitive glory. A real mixed bag of existential lollies awaits your post-singlet days – and if you’re gonna rely on Me to help you navigate that shit, put this nonsense behind you now, quick smart.

//GOD

Comments

Roadkill Monday, 25 Apr 2022 at 07:55 pm new

That time brutus said…
“as for revulsion , inciting hatred, serious contempt, there seems to be people on here that don't understand what they are saying and how their comments can be translated into insults/attacks etc...”

Then goes onto say…
“secular people will burn in Hell”

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 09:39 am new

it is maybe offensive to non-believers, as if you don't believe in God/Bible/Jesus , why would you then be offended by something you don't believe in?

I think the Religious Discrimination Bill serves the so called Religious Institutions such as Hillsong...I don't think it's a good thing!

bluediamond Monday, 25 Apr 2022 at 06:55 pm new

Good to see this convo has returned to a much more polite and open discussion than where it was going. Respect to all that are showing it. Good stuff.

Tristan Goose Monday, 25 Apr 2022 at 09:21 pm new

Feel like this is just anti Brazilianness coated in secularism. Brazil doesn't have life as easy as Australia, who cares if they look for something bigger to help them get through it all.

billie Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 12:30 pm new

I concur

stunet Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 12:53 pm new

Come on, really?

I've championed the surfing of all the Brazilian's, never got on the anti-Brazo bus, even hired a Brazilian journo to cover comps for us.

In fact, Julio would tell you outright that your knowledge of Toledo, Medina, and TTW - the three main culprits - is hopelessly off the mark, and has more than a whiff of racism about it.

Medina was raised in a comfortable middle-class family in Maresias, Toledo is a second-generation pro who's travelled the world his whole life, and TTW has two surfing parents (Hawaiian and Brazilian) and splits time between both countries.

Poor? Get your facts right, mate.

billie Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 08:48 pm new

It is a poor country (by comparison to Austrlia). And, the culture is set by the majority (poor). These facts are right.
Australia is a wealthy country where the culture has been set by emotion avoiding English who adore rugby league and heroes who don't seem to try too hard. Probably why so many skippys hate the highly emotional Brazzos? I'm an emotional wog, FUCKEN LOVE THE BRAZZOS!!!

stunet Wednesday, 27 Apr 2022 at 06:38 am new

Yes, I do too.

Unlike you, I even think some of them are capable of independent thought.

suchas Monday, 25 Apr 2022 at 09:27 pm new

Dear God, if you are the creator of all things, did you have anything to do with hell?
https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/articles/a-visitors-guide-to-dantes-n...

burleigh Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 10:03 am new

Does anyone notice that when you tell happy clappers that god isn’t real is the same as when you tell a WWE fan that it’s also not real.

Both dilusional fruitloops

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 10:38 am new

nothing you can say on here can change the minds of those who believe in God .

Burleigh you choose your faith/belief that God does not exist , so that's your religion which is faith based as you cannot prove God doesn't exist?

calling people fruitloops/delusional , is your opinion , but based on which facts?

burleigh Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 10:52 am new

Brutus, I believe that god doesnt exist because in over 2000 years there is no proof. its 2022 and still nothing.
I choose that god doesnt exist because of the atrocities that happen at the hands of his men, inside his churches.
I choose that god doesnt exist because of millions upon millions of children die each year due to disease/hunger all while the church gets richer and richer.

Want me to go on?

I would love to believe that when we die we go to a higher place, but im not going to do so in blind faith with no proof. I think we all want to believe that when we die it isn't the end and you get to see loved ones again.

But without proof its just a fairytail IMO.

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 12:28 pm new

I have posted enough proof here for believers......you don't accept it as you either don't read it or dismiss it as propaganda....which is your prerogative !

Just because you don't understand that God never promised there wouldn't be hardship /problems, trials.......Romans 5:3 We can rejoice , when we run into problems and trials for we know that they help us develop endurance . Endurance develops strength of character , and character strengthens our confident hope of salvation....."

burleigh Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 12:49 pm new

Proof for believers. Lol you’re going to have to do better than that Brutus.

Imagine using that analogy for pedos. Oh wait, sorry…. they go hand in hand inside the church.

Your god never promised there wouldn’t be the worst kind of abuse inside the walls of him own home? Fuck mate that’s sick.

Imagine those poor children just wishing there was an actual god to stop the abuse, put yourself in their shoes. Then listen to these entitled god bothers thanking god for a fucking wave.

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 04:46 pm new

what I see/read as proof , you dismiss as fairy tales......so I have faith in what I read as it has been peer reviewed.....

when you think there are over 2m kids being trafficked world wide in the child sex industry and all the woes that mankind does...you want to blame a God that doesn't exist??

As for pedos going hand in hand with the church....do you have any idea how big paedophilia is outside the church?

I am going to have to sign off soon as I have an incredible amount of work coming up and also looks like some insane surf coming at alst......

burleigh Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 05:03 pm new

Go surf Brutus. Hopefully god sends you a couple of tubes.

Jelly Flater Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 05:10 pm new

Haha ;)
Wow…

- denial … deflection … and excuses

What a selfish sad sack you are brutus ;)
Didn’t know that being insensitive and callous was part of the doctrine…

Run along now ;);)

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 05:34 pm new

haha jelly......of course you would see me as a selfish sad sack , insensitive /callous.......as I question you lack of being/future which you can't answer because you only attack the messenger....not the issues.......intellect and IQ seriously questioned here...all ya got is personal attacks....words more empty words.....no hope!
It's OK I will leave and take my empirical evidence with me, LOL!

Gusset Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 01:33 pm new

brutus, faith is belief without proof. Belief in religious doctrine not based on facts, evidence or empirical research - belief in the un-believable. But if you look at the evidence and compare it with the monotheistic religions, judaism, Christianity and islam, who by the way all worship the same deity - the god of Abraham, there is overwhelming evidence to prove the non existence of your god.

I could write a thesis on the subject but will point out just some of the contradictions and falsehoods.

Let’s start at the beginning. Bible scholars based on the generational evidence in the book of Genesis have stated that the universe is circa 4,500 years old. Based on numerous proven scientific dating methods the universe is 14 billion years old.

It is obvious that god was created in the image of man, not man was created in the image of god. Just by reading the old testament I am appalled by the behaviour imposed on man by god. Human slavery, infanticide (child sacrifice), human sacrifice, animal sacrifice, genocide, sexual slavery, stoning to death of adulterous women, stoning to death of homosexuals - always men.

Even god himself gets in on the act of premeditated mass murder when he murders, by drowning, the entire human race except for Noah and his family.

There are numerous examples where the archeological evidence disproves the bible verses. For example, camels being in a certain area at a given time when the archeological evidence proves that incorrect. I could go on….and on.

The new testament isn’t much better. The birth of Jesus did not occur. They went to Bethlehem for Jesus’s birth during the reign of Herod - the only problem is according to Roman and Hebrew writings, Herod died 9 years before the birth of Jesus. So the killing of the children did not occur either. And another fact is that the census performed by the Romans for tax purposes did not happen until 5 years after the bibles birthdate of Jesus. Nothing is accurate - it was written 60 - 100 years after christ and there are no eye witnesses or corroborating evidence.

There is so much more I could say but I think I have made my point.

Oh, just one more thing brutus - I think you suffer from CPC (christian persecution complex) look it up. It’s when you think you are being victimised, persecuted, bullied or vilified by people when all they do is express a contrary view or opinion to you. This is instilled in christians by the teachings of Paul.

Cheers - please relax and stop trolling.

goofyfoot Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 01:30 pm new

cant wait for the reply to this, strap yourself in its gunna be a doozy

Jelly Flater Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 02:12 pm new

Thank you for having the guts to share your past stuff with us on here and for this contribution gusset…

Much respect to you

Gusset Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 02:59 pm new

Thanks JF. It's certainly been a difficult journey but life is pretty good now. The ocean and music has been my saviour. Cheers.

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 05:13 pm new

faith is belief without proof......so what is proof?

Do you believe in.....Anzac day and the slaughter of young Australian troops being used as cannon fodder by the English...do you believe in any historical events...if so why....or do you have faith that what was written was true ?

you talk about empirical proof/evidence and say that there is overwhelming evidence that there is no God.

You then use your version of events as proof..huh , unless that's your version of empirical evidence?

your version of history and saying God is a mass murderer is relative to your beliefs or lack of .

your comment on Herod and the birth of Jesus ...can you post empirical proof ....as all I can find is that Jesus was probably born in 4 BC and Herod died in 1BC...https://www.biblicalarchaeology.org/daily/people-cultures-in-the-bible/…

Yeah there 's a lot of conjecture ......but the whole basis of what you say cannot be proved by you...as there are no empirical facts/evidence....or.....please post some links to your evidence ??

as for your CPC claim.....there is nobody here that could possibly intimidate me physically or mentally.....and as you have just proved , does your facts and evidence exist.....??

If you think I am trolling , why would you even bother to post your unfounded claims.....more discussion?

Gusset Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 07:18 pm new

brutus, of course a bible society is going to try and change the dates of what has been established and accepted for nearly two millennia - it satisfies their cognitive dissonance. The link you posted supports my comments Herod 13BC christ 4BC. I'm not going to do your research for you but may I suggest you don't always look for evidence or facts in bible run websites as you will always get the answer that YOU are looking for. There are secular texts and research that backs up what I have written. No one here that could intimidate you physically or mentally? Sounds like pride - one of the deadly sins. Pride cometh before a fall brutus.

By the way the story of Noah's ark is in your book of fairy tales that you believe is all factual - so, did god flood the earth and drown the entire human race or not?

Jelly Flater Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 09:18 pm new

This is excellent gusset ;)

Hope you are taking notes brutus.

The links / bible run websites provide you with artificial intelligence…

- brutus u are running on empty on AI !

Quick… slither and slide… hide… or make something up or try get somebody else to explain it for u ;);)

goofyfoot Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 07:15 pm new

Why do you keep bringing up Anzac Day and questioning if it actually happened you insensitive fuckwit?
There are people alive (or were until very recently) who were there!
People on here who’s relatives died there.

And you keep trying to relate it to your brainwashed fucking fairytales that you believe in.
Wtf is wrong with you you’re seriously a deranged individual.
How anyone respects you with the absolute shit you say is beyond me.
You need serious help.

Roadkill Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 10:48 am new

Can anyone prove the tooth fairy doesn’t exist? No, thus the tooth fairy is real.

Can anyone prove a bunyip doesn’t exist? No, thus the bunyip is real.

Can anyone prove the boogeyman doesn’t exist? No, thus the boogeyman is real.

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 12:41 pm new

haha RK, so is there any proof out there that the Tooth Fairy/bunyip/boogeyman does exist?

As there is plenty of proof that Jesus did exist , and the Gospels are real!

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 12:41 pm new

haha RK, so is there any proof out there that the Tooth Fairy/bunyip/boogeyman does exist?

As there is plenty of proof that Jesus did exist , and the Gospels are real!

bonza Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 01:30 pm new

bunyips are real.

Bustard Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 11:08 am new

George Constanza.... " its not a lie....if you believe it "

AndyM Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 12:42 pm new

@Brutus

"I have posted an excellent book , based on facts...written by an Indian Intellectual , Vishal Mangalwadi...." the Book that made your World or How the Bible created the soul of Western Civilization....."

Factual foundation?
You can't be serious, you must be trolling.

"What triggered the Wests passion for scientific, medical and technological advancement....."

Brutus, the West had to reject religious dogma so as to progress scientifically - religion held back science for thousands of years and continues to do so.
We've been through this before.
The Enlightenment was the key to moving towards separating church and state and instead obtaining reason by means of evidence as opposed to pure belief.

"How the Bible has uniquely equipped the west to cultivate compassion, human rights, prosperity and strong families."

Uniquely equipped? That pong in the air surrounding that comment is the whiff of racism.

"the role of the Bible in the transformation of education"

Really? See "enlightenment".

"How the Bible created fertile ground for women to find social and economic empowerment"

You're fucking kidding.

I hope you're trolling otherwise it's quite sad for you.

If you're serious, I'd say your intellectual capabilities are up there with a parsnip.

Jelly Flater Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 01:17 pm new

Well said andym …

I thought brutus was more just a potato head but yeh parsnip intellectual sounds very appropriate;)

After all… there is evidence jesus’ earthly dad had the ‘pa-snip’ - otherwise dear mary wouldn’t have been able to immaculately conceive.

Facts ;)

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 01:29 pm new

could you please post some of your facts that refute Vishals book?

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 01:27 pm new

Andy the person who wrote the book is considered one of India's foremost intellectuals...way beyond you or I.....so your criticism and comments are irrelevant , as you haven't read it or the peer reviews...
So your opinion is based on what factual basis?

AndyM Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 02:00 pm new

Oh my fucking god
You want to put 500 or 600 years of established history against one fella?
Copernicus to Galileo to Gutenberg and pretty much every great thinker or scientist you could name?

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 02:52 pm new

so you can name drop , so what has Capernicus/Galileo/Gutenberg written that contradicts Vishal?

Gusset Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 01:29 pm new

Excellent book and comment - parsnip indeed.

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 02:56 pm new

perhaps I could be addressed as Mr Parsnip.....so you read Vishal's book....blew me away on how the medieval era was so productive!

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 05:27 pm new

what book did you read?

Jelly Flater Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 01:47 pm new

Um….. brutus
About those questions… ;)

You didn’t / couldn’t answer them ;);)

They are simple questions, a simple answer should suffice. What the fark don’t you get about it ? ;);)

Maybe listening… considering… and even contemplating something and then being able to answer using content from your own brain and direct life experience may work ;) …you never know!

You might not need a farkn book to try and translate what you obviously can’t explain clearly for yourself ;)

I’m not demanding any answers… I’m asking you why you can’t actually answer in a direct and practical way - according to you ;) I’m guessing/hoping you still have that capability - maybe not tho ?

I didn’t ask vishal mangalwadi to explain anything here. And what he explains is only partially accurate yet thought provoking… However, I asked you if you are responsible and accountable for your own thoughts, feelings and emotions ;)

If you don’t know - it’s ok to say you don’t know. Not knowing is not a sin ;)

So…

Q. Who creates your feelings / impulses / reactions ?

And :

Q. How is the piece not satire ?

-brutus boldly claims :

‘you call it Satire , as a way of playing down the negative reactions and comments.......’

Um… no…. I call it satire because it is clearly written tongue in cheek and the content is silly and clearly a bit of fun. Do you get that bit ? ;)
It is an observation of what is actually written in the piece - not what comments are there in response to it !

The negative ‘reactions’ are from negative people who feed their own negative emotions and pretend someone is enforcing those feelings upon them ;);) As I’ve stated before - a belief is not based in reality and will often allow a person to create a negative state when that belief ultimately clashes with reality … it is an inevitability ;)

Be accountable for how you feel, take responsibility for your choices and (wait for it)… try engage some self control ;)

You apply the meaning because you have a fixed position / bias according to your interpretation of what god is…

You actually call it vilification as a means to deflect your own misery / outrage and this is created by you - influencing and driving your internal state. Don’t try blame others or an ‘author’ or whoever for you incorrectly perceiving something for what it is - as then your demeanour / character is simply at the mercy of an outside source ;)

You get that ? ;);)
And that is probably not conducive to experiencing and exhibiting respect, humility, openness and a willingness to learn and grow…

You search for outrage, search for victim status, inflate the hysteria about your interpretation of the secular world and spend an enormous amount of time and energy reinforcing that you have the ‘answers’ and the ‘facts’ and the ‘evidence’ ;) …

You could always just exclaim that it is god that makes you feel a certain way… ay ;);)

Is god really doing the doing tho ? ;)

Or just feeding the delusion and reinforcing the fantasy ? ;);)

Jelly Flater Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 01:56 pm new

brutus says to andym :

‘you cannot post an argument , just knee jerk emotion based on your intellect/secular beliefs?’

Ummm. Are you yet to accuse anyone of things you are evidently guilty of ?
The hypocrisy just gathers momentum ;)

- your arguments brutus are based on knee jerk emotion based on your intellect / religious beliefs aren’t they ???

Oops. My bad… that would require an intellect. Apologies to any offended parsnips, it’s been a rough ride since god had such a profound literary contribution and then just fucked off and went silent ? ;)

Kind of like when the bible was composed… atleast ‘god’ is consistent …

-certainly got a sense of humour too ;)

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 03:09 pm new

my points come from peer reviewed facts...no knee jerk emotion.....you guys seem to think that your opinions which seem to be based on headlines and heresay.
So what am I being hypocritical of . I post facts you guys post unsubstantiated opinions coming from the incredible depths of your intellects....or lack of?

frog Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 07:09 pm new

Your proof boils down to:
I believe because someone else believes, who believes because someone else believed, who believed because .. .

Repeat endlessly.

A reason to do so if that is enough for you but it is not proof.

udo Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 02:27 pm new

Brutus said :
Gee Udo.......are you white ?

-------------------------------------------------
Yes i Identify as White...

Are you White ? .... how do you Identify in 2022 ??

Brutus said : Can you be more Specific

WTF.....No i can not its a straightforward Question ?

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 03:04 pm new

you said white...I said I don't see my identity as white of black , but see myself as an Australian...where my definition of an Australian is anybody and everybody who lives in Australia transcends race.......and being one of Gods Children means , all of us are equal in Gods eyes and race doesn't come into it....

So Udo once again I'll ask.......you see yourself as white....once upon a time I thought I was a blackfella , because of the racism directed at me.....but found this was even more divisive and polarizing as if you were not white.....you were of an inferior race.......so after much contemplation and consultation with Indigenous elders......we are Australian, embracing all people who want to be Australians........but there are those who just choose to be white!

mcbain Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 02:54 pm new

Jeepers, the God Delusion Dawkins dorks are ploughing hard in here.

Gusset Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 03:05 pm new

God is NOT Great by Christopher Hitchens is better.

mcbain Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 03:29 pm new

Nope, they are both crap.

Gusset Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 04:00 pm new

Oh dear mcbain - that comment says a lot about you. Hitchens and Dawkins are considered as some of the greatest intellects of our time - so if you took absolutely nothing away from reading them other than "both are crap" it's a reflection of your illiberal and bigoted mindset or you simply do not understand their arguments. Have you read the books?

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 05:16 pm new

Hitchens and Dawkins , greatest intellects of our time...how about C S Lewis?

mcbain Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 08:28 pm new

Yep, both narrow and shallow. I agree Hitchens may have the jump on Dawko, but that is where you and I part ways. Don't take it to heart though, if you enjoyed them, that's great!

burleigh Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 03:36 pm new

A Catholic priest, a child molester and a liar walks into a bar.

The barkeep throws a glance and says "You're the first person in here tonight"

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 05:20 pm new

nice , how about a /mass murderer/rapist/child molester/thief walks into a bar and the barkeeper says 'your the first whiteman in here tonite!"

seeds Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 05:58 pm new

Brutus seriously? You’re back to this. White man’s disease? Only white men do these things? What is wrong with you?

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 07:31 pm new

not serious , but seems peoples whiteness is threatened , by posting a joke .......just trying to expose what is a joke to some people is not o others!

udo Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 06:44 pm new

Nice Brutus-
Mass Murderer /Rapist /Child Molester/ Thief and he is a Whiteman
Thats definitely better than my old Altar Boy Joke from 2015 that you keep Harping on about..

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 07:29 pm new

haha Udo.......once upon a time , I lived and believed that white people were Mass murderers/rapists/child molesters/thieves and simply put a malevolent evil sent to Australia ...I would have included you in this category as you are white and all white people...because I suffered racism as did all indigenous Australians.

Isn't amazing how one can evolve and understand not to judge the majority of the actions of the minority....educating myself and discussing white/colonial Australia's past and how people view the past, changed my thinking and becoming a Born again Christian , teaches forgiveness and to embrace you enemies ......so I can admit that what I posted is antiquated , can you actually say you were wrong in making fun of priests....but making fun of altar boys who have been raped ....well any thoughts on that?

udo Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 07:38 pm new

Brutus are you saying you are an Indigenous Australian ?

Jelly Flater Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 03:47 pm new

And again…. ;)
- brutus says this :

‘I have posted enough proof here for believers......you don't accept it as you either don't read it or dismiss it as propaganda....’

Um… in your expert opinion, or using the expert facts and evidence and peer reviewed intellect of others - how would u like to disprove some stuff that might not align with your narrative / delusion / fantasy / imagination / memory / insanity ;)

Hope u don’t mind me reposting this gusset but…. paging brutus ;);)

‘brutus, faith is belief without proof. Belief in religious doctrine not based on facts, evidence or empirical research - belief in the un-believable. But if you look at the evidence and compare it with the monotheistic religions, judaism, Christianity and islam, who by the way all worship the same deity - the god of Abraham, there is overwhelming evidence to prove the non existence of your god.

I could write a thesis on the subject but will point out just some of the contradictions and falsehoods.

Let’s start at the beginning. Bible scholars based on the generational evidence in the book of Genesis have stated that the universe is circa 4,500 years old. Based on numerous proven scientific dating methods the universe is 14 billion years old.

It is obvious that god was created in the image of man, not man was created in the image of god. Just by reading the old testament I am appalled by the behaviour imposed on man by god. Human slavery, infanticide (child sacrifice), human sacrifice, animal sacrifice, genocide, sexual slavery, stoning to death of adulterous women, stoning to death of homosexuals - always men.

Even god himself gets in on the act of premeditated mass murder when he murders, by drowning, the entire human race except for Noah and his family.

There are numerous examples where the archeological evidence disproves the bible verses. For example, camels being in a certain area at a given time when the archeological evidence proves that incorrect. I could go on….and on.

The new testament isn’t much better. The birth of Jesus did not occur. They went to Bethlehem for Jesus’s birth during the reign of Herod - the only problem is according to Roman and Hebrew writings, Herod died 9 years before the birth of Jesus. So the killing of the children did not occur either. And another fact is that the census performed by the Romans for tax purposes did not happen until 5 years after the bibles birthdate of Jesus. Nothing is accurate - it was written 60 - 100 years after christ and there are no eye witnesses or corroborating evidence.

There is so much more I could say but I think I have made my point.

Oh, just one more thing brutus - I think you suffer from CPC (christian persecution complex) look it up. It’s when you think you are being victimised, persecuted, bullied or vilified by people when all they do is express a contrary view or opinion to you. This is instilled in christians by the teachings of Paul.

Cheers - please relax and stop trolling.’

;);)

And…
Just a question… do you create your own emotions / impulses / feelings etc ?

Y or N will do ;)
Simple ;);)

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 07:32 pm new

yes...happy now?

Jelly Flater Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 08:40 pm new

Well done brutus!

Even though the god enforced timeframe for a sane and rational person to answer the question had expired, god is all merciful and forgiving ;)

You now have an eternal subscription / sponsorship with parsnip and moonbeam magazine ;)

Don’t change your mind tho or it’s a good chance you’ll burn in hellfire ! ;)

ringmaster Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 04:48 pm new

This particular forum, thread, whatever you want to call it is the perfect example of how religion in pretty well all shapes and forms is such a divisive, problematic clusterfuck.

How much better the world would be if it had died a quick death once humans had evolved to the level where we gained an understanding of science and how we fit in to the grand scheme of things.

Gusset Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 05:01 pm new

I think we need a little bit of humorous relief.

THE FACT THAT THERE IS A HIGHWAY TO HELL AND ONLY A STAIRWAY TO HEAVEN SAYS A LOT ABOUT ANTICIPATED TRAFFIC NUMBERS.

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 05:22 pm new

Amen, that's the first thing you have said that makes sense!

Jelly Flater Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 05:39 pm new

Um brutus ;)

Can you make sense of the Y or N question…? ? ?

Do you have an answer ?

I mean - u being an expert and peer reviewed fact finder on simple questions… ;)

old-dog Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 05:21 pm new

I always thought it was an unwritten law that you don't have a go at peoples religious beliefs, it's a bit like stealing from tents in campgrounds, rooting your mates chick or pissing in someone's jug of VB. Silly me.

tubeshooter Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 05:37 pm new

The first two I don't condone. But pissing in someones jug of VB surely isn't off limits.? Is it.?

fcalmon Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 05:23 pm new

545 comments. New record?

Roadkill Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 05:27 pm new

Born again…or those that had a shit life and then find religion…are the absolute worst kind of religious zealots. That can be christian, muslim etc etc. They are blind to any sort of reality.

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 05:35 pm new

So what was your reality again?

Roadkill Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 05:43 pm new

You seem to be ignoring this brutus, do you think homosexuality is a choice or are you are born gay?

Can a gay person become hetrosexual?

Do you agree with what the bible says about homosexuality?

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 07:33 pm new

so what does the Bible say about homosexuality?

Jelly Flater Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 05:43 pm new

@brutus…

Maybe the question you are more suited to ponder is :

- what is reality ? ;);)

Not sure it exists in ‘your’ world ;)

Roadkill Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 05:45 pm new

That time brutus said….When have I not answered a question?

Then demands others answer his questions.

Jelly Flater Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 06:16 pm new

A watered down request to brutus ;);)
… or is he slithering away to hibernate !

‘Um…..
About those questions… ;)

You didn’t / couldn’t answer them ;);)

I’m not demanding any answers… I’m asking you why you can’t actually answer in a direct and practical way - according to you ;) I’m guessing/hoping you still have that capability - maybe not tho ?

I asked you if you are responsible and accountable for your own thoughts, feelings and emotions ;)

If you don’t know - it’s ok to say you don’t know. Not knowing is not a sin ;)

So…

Q. Who creates your feelings / impulses / reactions ?

And :

Q. How is the piece not satire ?

-brutus boldly claims :

‘you call it Satire , as a way of playing down the negative reactions and comments.......’

Um… no…. I call it satire because it is clearly written tongue in cheek and the content is silly and clearly a bit of fun. Do you get that bit ? ;)
It is an observation of what is actually written in the piece - not what comments are there in response to it !

The negative ‘reactions’ are from negative people who feed their own negative emotions and pretend someone is enforcing those feelings upon them ;);) As I’ve stated before - a belief is not based in reality and will often allow a person to create a negative state when that belief ultimately clashes with reality … it is an inevitability ;)

Be accountable for how you feel, take responsibility for your choices and (wait for it)… try engage some self control ;)

You apply the meaning because you have a fixed position / bias according to your interpretation of what god is…

You actually call it vilification as a means to deflect your own misery / outrage and this is created by you - influencing and driving your internal state. Don’t try blame others or an ‘author’ or whoever for you incorrectly perceiving something for what it is - as then your demeanour / character is simply at the mercy of an outside source ;)

You get that ? ;);)
And that is probably not conducive to experiencing and exhibiting respect, humility, openness and a willingness to learn and grow…

You search for outrage, search for victim status, inflate the hysteria about your interpretation of the secular world and spend an enormous amount of time and energy reinforcing that you have the ‘answers’ and the ‘facts’ and the ‘evidence’ ;) …

You could always just exclaim that it is god that makes you feel a certain way… ay ;);)

Is god really doing the doing tho ? ;)

Or just feeding the delusion and reinforcing the fantasy ? ;);) ‘

- It’s ok brutus… there is no right or wrong answer ;)

There will be no punishment ;)

Are you frightened / hesitant in case you may burn ‘your’ bridge to god ?…

- there could be the possibility of winning an eternal subscription to parsnip and moonbeam magazine ;);)

Jelly Flater Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 06:55 pm new

Anyway… no rush brutus ;);)

You say:

‘haha jelly......of course you would see me as a selfish sad sack , insensitive /callous.......as I question you lack of being/future which you can't answer because you only attack the messenger....not the issues.......intellect and IQ seriously questioned here...all ya got is personal attacks....words more empty words.....no hope!
It's OK I will leave and take my empirical evidence with me, LOL!‘

I can’t answer because I only attack the messenger ?

‘Intellect and IQ seriously questioned here’ - yep you said it brutus. Spot on ;)

You can’t answer a Y or N question and you are still accusing others of your own cowardice …

Keep questioning that IQ ;);)
Maybe answer the question for yourself.

Good luck to you brutus

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 07:39 pm new

No luck needed here!!

Jelly Flater Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 07:58 pm new

Haha…
U really can’t help yaself can u ;)

And your exclamation…
Your words : ‘no hope ! ‘
More projection ;)

You’ve provided enough evidence here…
I personally reckon you’ve got or had severe addiction / dependence issues and your religion is now your diversionary tactic…

It’s how u occupy / distract the peanut brain ;)

That’s why I wish u luck and all the best ;)

The arrogant and incessant accusatory tone and obvious lack of self awareness is something god must be very proud of… coz you’re gods child after all ;);)

Your words again there haha

I reckon a child could answer a Y or N question ;)

Maybe….
It’s ok… daddy will save you

stunet Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 07:17 pm new

Last comments, people.

Tomorrow AM I'm gonna roll the rock over this cavernous comment section.

Bury it away for good.

Finnbob the terror Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 07:34 pm new

Thank God

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 07:38 pm new

yes he wrote the article , LOL, and now he's taking it down......waaaaaahhhhhhhh.....SN God has had enough.......LOL.....

Jelly Flater Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 08:07 pm new

Maybe he’s being merciful to you brutus so the potential for further embarrassment and displays of narcissism and hypocrisy won’t stain the christains ;)

He sounds like an actual ‘man for others’ - one who even wants to ‘treat others as he would like to be treated’ ;)

Funny - u proclaim to follow jesus’ teachings yet all the hallmarks and traits are absent in the brutus !

Time to send u in ;););)
What a fraud…

(I’ll just use lower case so to appeal to brutus’ low IQ)

lololololololololol

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 10:05 pm new

LOL, jelly lets call it a day.....everything you say about me is actually how I see you.......the difference is your self appointed genius status.........philosophically weak , and no substance to any of your claims......been interesting to say the least , I learnt a lot here.......but time to get back to reality and stop playing with people who 's MO seems negative dark insults...maybe we will meet up one day in the surf.....shit do you surf, LOL?

Jelly Flater Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 10:23 pm new

Yes brutus , I do ;)

Over 40 yrs in the water and still goin, like yourself…

I’m hoping you can see past the ‘insults’ - try not focus on what doesn’t serve you ;)

All the best, hope you get some waves

brutus Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 07:35 pm new

what Stu...you posted the article , getting a bit much for you?

Jelly Flater Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 08:52 pm new

Haha ;)

Maybe brutus is concerned once it’s gone he’ll be forced into trying to push this stuff in the real world. Uh oh ;) That’s gonna go well…

Or…

- just go to an ‘all things religion’ thread instead and try school others on purely christian rhetoric and doctrine instead of exploring and learning and sharing about…… ‘all things religion’ !

Yay ;)

Jelly Flater Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 07:37 pm new

Fair enough stu ;)

Careful tho…

After three days - if the rock is rolled back - the thread will have mysteriously vanished up a moonbeam.

Fortunately the author will also be back home and will chill at the spirits bar ;)

Apparently someone said it’ll return and provide ‘salvation’ at some point…

But most understand that’s a load of shit ;)

And most are ok with that too

Peace to all ;);)

Roadkill Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 07:47 pm new

I’m ganna pretend it’s still here. I believe it is still here….therefore it is still here. I can’t prove it will still be here.. but, ya know….it will be here..I hope it is still here because if it’s not here everything I believe is just a big lie..so..it ain’t going anywhere.

Jelly Flater Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 08:00 pm new

Hahahahaha ;)

Facts

Jelly Flater Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 07:43 pm new

You’re the one who’s flaking out here brutus..

- when your IQ / intellect not only is unable to make sense of a Y or a N question, whilst accusing everyone of needing evidence etc, things kinda spk for them self ;););)

All the best

fcalmon Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 08:43 pm new

C’mon Stu, let it roll. This is more entertaining than any television show. This Brutus is hilarious and I have bought a ton of popcorn….

bluediamond Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 08:49 pm new

The level of vitriol and abusive comments directed at one person on this post is beyond disgusting. All by nameless people. @roadkill, @goofyfoot, @simsurf @jellyflater @alfredwallace. Why not put your name to your comments if you're going to rip into someone who you know on a public forum. Do you believe you're 2 separate people...an online person and the real you. What a fucking joke.
It's one thing to argue your beliefs. It's another to deride another person for theirs.
In doing so you've made yourselves look a whole level lower than the belief systems you're so vehemently opposing.
Good on ya Brutus for keeping a cool head and not attacking other posters, but just asking questions. Your beliefs are different to mine, it doesn't bother me in the slightest nor should it.

Roadkill Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 08:59 pm new

Bd…always a flog. Never smart enough recognise all sides..you and brutus could have a pity party together.
Butus, like you…can give but can’t take it when given back.

Snowflakes united….lmao.

Jelly Flater Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 09:02 pm new

@bd
No one here is bothered but u cupcake ;)

As the most experienced and qualified contributor here (other than god) stated :

(Once again hope u don’t mind gusset)

‘ brutus - I think you suffer from CPC (christian persecution complex) look it up. It’s when you think you are being victimised, persecuted, bullied or vilified by people when all they do is express a contrary view or opinion to you. This is instilled in christians by the teachings of Paul. ‘

- Is that u paul ? U can go now paul ;);)
Thanks for the input tho

goofyfoot Wednesday, 27 Apr 2022 at 01:59 am new

Bd if you respect this guy because he can shape a surfboard that’s great, I don’t.

Fact is he on numerous occasions on this thread has brought up Anzac day and compared it to Jesus and questioned whether it happened because “I wasn’t there so how do I know it’s true”.

My pop served in PNG in ww2 and his two brothers also, he returned, they didn’t.
For this disrespectful flog to be so insensitive to something close to a lot of people (that actually happened) just shows how his brain works.

The guys an a-grade moron, if me saying that and not putting my real name to it causes you think less of me that’s perfectly fine, I won’t be losing any sleep over it.

Speaking of sleep, it’s late, babies gone back to sleep now so am I.
This is the last time I’m posting on this thread. Wasted too much time on here already.

bluediamond Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 09:05 pm new

Anonymous comments and attacks from anonymous nobodies. Your lack of bravery and courage has been duly noted. Love from Paul

Jelly Flater Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 09:06 pm new

Haha ;);)
- bd congratulated brutus on ‘keeping a cool head and not attacking other posters’

Haha this stuff is gold ;)
You couldn’t make this shit up…

Or could you ? ;);)

Hypocrites and deluded ones unite !
Letssssss gooooo ;) haha

bluediamond Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 09:19 pm new

No name, no substance. How is that an attack? You're either the same person as the person posting your comments, or you're admitting you're two different people. If you can't put your name to your personal attacks and name calling, (to someone who you do know) then you lack courage. Is there anything clearer? Deflecting an obvious truth with more attacks. You sir, seem to have the issues here.
You can walk up to Brutus and he'd have no clue who you are. Isn't that an unfair advantage.
So prove your worth. You guys are the ones all attacking him. Put your name to it. Since you are all riding the moral highground on this.
I know you won't...but i'm interested as to why not??

Jelly Flater Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 09:35 pm new

Um… bd

Thanks again for your input, didn’t know there was a self appointed moderator and conditions setter …

There are no unfair advantages. You’re as big a moron as brutus, if you wanna try defend him go for it ;);)

You’re also defending bigotry, an inflated sense of ego - as well as vouching for prejudice and bigotry…

Good on ya u dickhead…
If what u say interests u as you say it does then you’re as lost and deluded as brutus minimus ;);)

Get a life…
You can go now Paul ;)

bluediamond Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 09:40 pm new

Weak as piss.

Jelly Flater Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 10:00 pm new

Brave words paul ;)

Maybe let it gooooooo…

Maybe brutus can spk for himself ?
- Oh. My bad ;);) … that’d b a stretch ;)

But…. anything is possible yeh - once the divine internet bible fact search engine is sparked to life, of course ;);)

bluediamond Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 10:17 pm new

No name no substance. Weaker than piss.

Jelly Flater Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 10:32 pm new

Um….

Love. Respect. Humbleness ;)

Thanks paul - you can go now ;);)

batfink Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 09:57 pm new

Oh blimey, I got to the end. Holey Cow.

Shows where we are as a nation, division, intolerance, how good is Australia.

DudeSweetDudeSweet Wednesday, 27 Apr 2022 at 04:28 am new

You think a few naughty words during a relatively mild discussion about religion is evidence of the deterioration of Australian society?

Almost anywhere else in the world the participants in a Barney over religion would be blowing each other up to prove their point.

The fact that Australians can remain so mellow whilst arguing about religion shows how tolerant we are. You should probably write an email to Swellnet complaining about it anyway I guess.

seeds Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 10:06 pm new

Long read hey Batfink. Did you get a bit trigger happy from exhaustion by the end of it.

Remigogo Tuesday, 26 Apr 2022 at 10:08 pm new

I'll give me two cents worth in this deteriating world order towards 600.