The Necessity of Reparation for Historic Injustices

Supafreak Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 04:23 pm new

There are a percentage of FNP that don’t want the voice to parliament and a percentage that don’t even know about the referendum let alone understand it . There is also a large percentage that do want a voice to parliament and I feel for them as if no vote gets up they will be shattered . It will be another demoralising kick in the teeth. Definitely no laughing matter or something to puff your chest out about but that’s the attitude of some in Australia. This can still be a proud moment in history for Australia .

goofyfoot Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 04:37 pm new

A Salty Dog wrote:

Indo said

Anyway its almost certain that we will get the last laugh on Saturday night.

Really mate, is that all it means to you.... something to laugh about.

Hahaha, yeah Dutto we got one back on Albo, hey great stuff. We win, that's all that matters.

I'll wager Dutton & Co will be running around patting each other on the back.

What a miserable, pathetic attitude from you lot.

Yep something to laugh about.

The guys a fucking germ.

There’s an insult for you indo.

basesix Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 05:07 pm new

Quite right Supa, and thank you for the role you have played in this thread while convoluting, it has made it vaguely readable. No champagne, no matter who wins, it is not sportsbet, it is a tragedy that it has become a big mental thing, particularly for the group in question being under the ABRUPT spotlight in a way that is horrrrrrificly affecting them.

Maybe some good will come from what has been exposed, but shit, we will have some clean up, with what this has caused within the greater aboriginal community. LNPALP be damned, fuckers, who cares.. Wish the 3% could determine the clean-up from this shitfuckery for themselves via a positive vote.

I LOVE that FNPs have differing opinions about the voice, it will make it dynamic, and scrutinised by vested interest people. I wouldn't want it any other way.

That a handful of people being given an ongoing national avisory role (about issues that affect them), somehow is seen as being 'all' aboriginal people being given power. Sad as fuck.

Supafreak Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 05:19 pm new

Watching on abc the other day Fran Kelly and another lady ( can’t remember her name ) talking about the fallout from the voice to parliament . There are many FNP hating the fact they are under the spotlight and getting abused just for existing, doesn’t matter what there position is on the voice . The government apparently anticipated this and set aside $10 million towards the mental health organisations that would be dealing with their anguish. The 13 no. hotline set up for FNP is under enormous pressure from not being able to handle the amount of calls their receiving . Imagine the desperation some FNP are feeling and just want to get on with their lives but are being subjected to racism from the ugly Australians that do exist . Edit heres a similar article https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-05-10/budget-allocates-millions-to-sup…

indo-dreaming Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 05:32 pm new

AndyM wrote:

"constant pointless insults "

Indo if you're going to make stuff up to suit your ideology, you're going to get called out.

Why should people give your absolute nonsense a free pass?

You've tried this on for years, people are sick of it.

Im sorry but despite your praise i cant take credit for making anything up, the view i share are held by many including Aboriginal people like Jacinta Price there has even been many books written around many of the things i discuss.

Yes i know you are sick of hearing views that are opposed to yours but thats your issue, deal with it honey.

Supafreak Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 05:44 pm new

DP

indo-dreaming Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 05:48 pm new

A Salty Dog wrote:

Indo said

Anyway its almost certain that we will get the last laugh on Saturday night.

Really mate, is that all it means to you.... something to laugh about.

Hahaha, yeah Dutto we got one back on Albo, hey great stuff. We win, that's all that matters.

I'll wager Dutton & Co will be running around patting each other on the back.

What a miserable, pathetic attitude from you lot.

Dude preventing this getting up has been important for many for a whole host of reasons discussed here for weeks, so no its not just about political point scoring thats only the icing on the cake,

Ive taken heaps of shit here, literally pages of abuse and name calling, just because my view differ's to others, I or anyone else shouldn't have to take that barrage of abuse like we have, so yeah I and im sure others will take pleasure in the fact we get the last laugh..

Supafreak Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 05:50 pm new

Mistruth be told https://www.themonthly.com.au/the-politics/rachel-withers/2023/10/12/mi… Misinformation has been a huge part of this campaign, on both social and traditional media; spreading conspiracies was an express tactic of the “No” outlet, Fair Australia, while an emboldened Peter Dutton’s flagrant lies continue to reach disturbing new heights. But this exchange caused many to shake their heads in despair. How many soft voters might have been persuaded to vote “Yes” were it not for the outright lies?……..” Anyone associated with the “No” campaign should be deeply ashamed of themselves, whether they themselves spread lies or simply denied the lies were taking place. “

goofyfoot Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 06:01 pm new

“ Ive taken heaps of shit here, literally pages of abuse and name calling, just because my view differ's to others”

You can’t be that fucken dense, surely?

AndyM Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 06:09 pm new

That’s the question.

I keep waiting to find out that Indo is a made-up character, a piss-take.

soggydog Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 06:34 pm new

You always punch down Indo, read some of your own comments and tell me you’re not going to get a bit of a kick out of a No result, like it’ll be something to celebrate and give the other side the bird with a smirk on your face. That’s what people see in your words
That’s why you cop so much shit.

Stu gave you a very tempered thought out response that didn’t pick sides, just provided another perspective and lived experience of the Middle East that could’ve triggered you to consider both sides and the events leading up to the weekend’s events. Go back and read your own reply, immediate and dismissive. You don’t discuss or debate, you just hammer. Weather you’re informed or not.
You enjoy whipping up the threads. You’ve even said it before.

That’s why the overwhelming sentiment amongst other posters is you’re a sniveling little cunt who loves to punch down.

indo-dreaming Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 06:47 pm new

Like i said you guys just cant handle view's that dont align with your own and think if gives you a right abuse others.

Here you are the majority in your views, but in the real world you are in the minority, the majority of Australia(especially 50+) are voting No and the majority of Australians including our PM are standing in solidarity with Israel.

seeds Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 07:04 pm new

No, it’s more than that.
Pontificating prat.

harrycoopr Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 07:18 pm new

indo-dreaming wrote:

Like i said you guys just cant handle view's that dont align with your own and think if gives you a right abuse others.

Here you are the majority in your views, but in the real world you are in the minority, the majority of Australia(especially 50+) are voting No and the majority of Australians including our PM are standing in solidarity with Israel.

"You can't handle the truth"
#boycottindo

soggydog Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 07:39 pm new

indo-dreaming wrote:

Like i said you guys just cant handle view's that dont align with your own and think if gives you a right abuse others.

Here you are the majority in your views, but in the real world you are in the minority, the majority of Australia(especially 50+) are voting No and the majority of Australians including our PM are standing in solidarity with Israel.

No original thoughts or reflection just justification of poor behaviour, “because I’m winning.”

Edit: Burleigh is a different story. I think, I don’t know, his position comes from a deep mistrust of government. Given the covid debacle I can understand and appreciate his grievances. I’ve seen no such avenue in anything you’ve presented.

goofyfoot Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 08:21 pm new

“ Edit: Burleigh is a different story. I think, I don’t know, his position comes from a deep mistrust of government. Given the covid debacle I can understand and appreciate his grievances. I’ve seen no such avenue in anything you’ve presented.”

Yep, and there are other posters on here who are voting No and that’s fine, no one has any issues with them.
It’s the way Indo comes across in his posts that make you want to hold his head underwater

seeds Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 08:25 pm new

Until the bubbles stop?

Reform Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 08:40 pm new

Totally uncool fellas - That's so uncool, Your inciting a murderous inclinations! This isn't okay, please detract and make good on this.

Supafreak Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 08:44 pm new

Laura Tingle on 7.30

Can only imagine the type of campaign leader of the no hopers is going to run next election.

Michael Adam Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 09:24 pm new

“Whilst there are some people in the No campaign who are absolutely racist and using the division argument as a cloak to conceal their racism, I’d wager most people there are not racist. These people have a hangover from what they saw during the vaccine insanity. They are voting no in protest; a fuck you to the government for what happened in 2020-22 and the continuing refusal to acknowledge it.

The idea this is a WEFerendum has strongly taken root. Can you blame anyone for holding that view after what happened between 2020-22? You can call it disinformation if you like, but it’s probably closer to the truth than the assertion “the vaccine is safe and effective”.

This is what the Yes campaign and Yes voters are unwilling or unable to accept. Most people are incapable of admitting they are wrong. They retreat to the comfort of the lie, because it absolves them of responsibility. Accepting the truth shatters their illusions and there is no death so sad, as the death of an illusion.

If someone prominent in the Yes campaign just said:

“Look, we accept what happened with respect to the vaccine was disgusting and anti-democratic. We were misled and manipulated by the military grade propaganda that was deployed on the population. Many of us engaged in behaviours that we now know were not only unhealthy and un-Australian but absolutely authoritarian. You were wronged and we acknowledge the hurt and suffering you endured in losing friends, family and careers for not wanting a vaccine that we admit was not only ineffective, but in many cases unsafe. The injuries are real and not the domain of tin foil hat conspiracy theory. We can’t imagine what it must’ve been like to be contemplating being excluded from society indefinitely. We are deeply sorry and understand how you might be skeptical, but please join us in recognising Indigenous people in the Constitution.”

Some acknowledgement and contrition would go a long way. But probably not. It’s sad how toxic the whole thing has become. Views are entrenched. The time for conciliation and understanding passed us by in 2021 and there’s nothing that will persuade the No crowd to vote Yes and there’s nothing that will persuade the Yes crowd that there are legitimate reasons to vote No which are not racist.”

Reform Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 09:38 pm new

Hey Michael Adam,
I cannot see any comparison between the Covid vaccine rollout and this referendum, They are two completely different entities. Why do you compare them and judge that all yes voters were in favour of the Vaccine rollout, that is total prejudice and is totally untrue that all yes voters were in favour of the vac rollout. I will not state my status here on this forum of the Vaccine rollout because, somehow, some way, everything said online is tracked by the Govt. Make no mistake they have info on every one of us. They know who you are and if they want to they will find you!

But vote yes! by all means. It is a privilege to vote yes for the Aboriginal people give them a F----g Voice ! FFS! They'll so much appreciate it, geez!

sypkan Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 09:41 pm new

totally michael adam!

the 'left' own that shit...

but they totally have not owned it!

they try to steam roll on like nothing happened... but the damage runs deep...

if they didn't play the cries of 'misinformation' game so hard, they might have pulled it off...

but they did... all over again... hard!

seeds Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 09:41 pm new

Reform wrote:

Totally uncool fellas - That's so uncool, Your inciting a murderous inclinations! This isn't okay, please detract and make good on this.

Fair enough but was in jest. I don’t think Indo would have taken it that way. If he did I apologise.

sypkan Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 09:42 pm new

now you've got me worried where you got that...

assuming it is a quote

seeds Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 09:45 pm new

Michael Adam wrote:

“Whilst there are some people in the No campaign who are absolutely racist and using the division argument as a cloak to conceal their racism, I’d wager most people there are not racist. These people have a hangover from what they saw during the vaccine insanity. They are voting no in protest; a fuck you to the government for what happened in 2020-22 and the continuing refusal to acknowledge it.

The idea this is a WEFerendum has strongly taken root. Can you blame anyone for holding that view after what happened between 2020-22? You can call it disinformation if you like, but it’s probably closer to the truth than the assertion “the vaccine is safe and effective”.

This is what the Yes campaign and Yes voters are unwilling or unable to accept. Most people are incapable of admitting they are wrong. They retreat to the comfort of the lie, because it absolves them of responsibility. Accepting the truth shatters their illusions and there is no death so sad, as the death of an illusion.

If someone prominent in the Yes campaign just said:

“Look, we accept what happened with respect to the vaccine was disgusting and anti-democratic. We were misled and manipulated by the military grade propaganda that was deployed on the population. Many of us engaged in behaviours that we now know were not only unhealthy and un-Australian but absolutely authoritarian. You were wronged and we acknowledge the hurt and suffering you endured in losing friends, family and careers for not wanting a vaccine that we admit was not only ineffective, but in many cases unsafe. The injuries are real and not the domain of tin foil hat conspiracy theory. We can’t imagine what it must’ve been like to be contemplating being excluded from society indefinitely. We are deeply sorry and understand how you might be skeptical, but please join us in recognising Indigenous people in the Constitution.”

Some acknowledgement and contrition would go a long way. But probably not. It’s sad how toxic the whole thing has become. Views are entrenched. The time for conciliation and understanding passed us by in 2021 and there’s nothing that will persuade the No crowd to vote Yes and there’s nothing that will persuade the Yes crowd that there are legitimate reasons to vote No which are not racist.”

Separate matters bozo. Shame you can’t see that and bring all that baggage with you.

sypkan Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 09:56 pm new

it's about trust reform

it was already at historical lows before the covid debacle

there's been a string of debacles...

where 'the left' cries 'conspiracy theory' and 'misinformation' all too loudly...

then 'history' shows otherwise...

you can't even call it history, the turnaround is so quick...

flat out obstinate denial is the vehement vitriolic practice, even after the world knows otherwise...

not all of the left, but a certain cohort is just plain delusional

they actually think they are pulling this shit off!

(looking at you mike carlton and friends)

seeds Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 09:52 pm new

sypkan wrote:

now you've got me worried where you got that...

assuming it is a quote

No. I’m the no more bubbles killer. Just haven’t made the news yet.

Supafreak Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 09:56 pm new

sypkan wrote:

totally michael adam!

the 'left' own that shit...

but they totally have not owned it!

they try to steam roll on like nothing happened... but the damage runs deep...

if they didn't play the cries of 'misinformation' game so hard, they might have pulled it off...

but they did... all over again... hard!

You have got to be fucking kidding me , it was scomo that shut the border and locked out australians from getting home , the federal government was In charge of aged care , you blame this current federal government for what happened during covid , fark me sypkan what is going on with you ?

AndyM Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 09:56 pm new

"you guys just cant handle view's that dont align with your own"

You can't really think that's the reason why you get so much stick.
Surely not.

Reform Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 10:02 pm new

seeds wrote:

sypkan wrote:

now you've got me worried where you got that...

assuming it is a quote

No. I’m the no more bubbles killer. Just haven’t made the news yet.

Yeah I know, I understand and that's pretty funny seeds, Thanks for your acknowledgement! cheers

sypkan Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 10:05 pm new

seeds wrote:

sypkan wrote:

now you've got me worried where you got that...

assuming it is a quote

No. I’m the no more bubbles killer. Just haven’t made the news yet.

I was referring to michael adam post

seeds Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 10:06 pm new

No problems

Supafreak Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 10:14 pm new

I can’t believe that people would want to punish FNP by voting no to stick it up the government, unfuckingbelievable. ! IMG-5263

sypkan Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 10:23 pm new

Supafreak wrote:

sypkan wrote:

totally michael adam!

the 'left' own that shit...

but they have totally not owned it!

they try to steam roll on like nothing ever happened... but the damage runs deep...

if they didn't play the cries of 'misinformation' game so hard, they might have pulled it off...

but they did... all over again... hard!

You have got to be fucking kidding me , it was scomo that shut the border and locked out australians from getting home , the federal government was In charge of aged care , you blame this current federal government for what happened during covid , fark me sypkan what is going on with you ?

no not at all supa

but actually, aside from aged care, what morrison did at the start of the pandemic was actually reasonable

...with what we knew at the time... and the nasty strain that hit italy...

my point is, as new information came to the fore, and we understood the virus better.... it was the right of politics that challenged 'the narrative'...

and 'the left' hung onto a broken narrative for way too long... about 2 years too long!!

some of em are still there now!

dan andrews, mcgowan, federal labor, the whole demorat's apparatus in the US...

be it about vaccines, their efficacy, the man made aspect, the lab, china generally, the 'cookers', ivermectin, the stats, the death count, how it was counted, the whole shit show...

all 'conspiracy theory' and 'misinformation'...

apparently...

you can throw russia, russia, russia, mk 1, 11, and 111, kompramat, pee tapes, russian bank debt, the twitter files, the laptop, biden corruption, the fbi, ... and a whole heap of other shit in there too...

the record ain't pretty

Supafreak Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 10:23 pm new

Ok so let’s punish FNP for what happened during covid, sounds fair and reasonable. I’m out.

seeds Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 10:24 pm new

Yeah I know Supa. Isn’t it sad. Confused I guess. Reality is last place. They walk amongst us.

sypkan Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 10:29 pm new

Supafreak wrote:

Ok so let’s punish FNP for what happened during covid, sounds fair and reasonable. I’m out.

that's not what Im saying at all...

(or michael adam... I think...)

just that, that's where the trust was burnt

and full loopyness set in

at all angles

including within the indigenous community

the WEF, WHO, and just about everything associated with 'the left' through covid did not conduct themselves well...

that's being kind

too kind!

basesix Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 10:33 pm new

breathe deep Supa. VJ is right, and you have made it all very clear, via balanced reasoning, for the many who have been listening, thank you.
(that cow thing? duuuude... hahah)

Reform Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 10:34 pm new

sypkan wrote:

seeds wrote:
sypkan wrote:

now you've got me worried where you got that...

assuming it is a quote

No. I’m the no more bubbles killer. Just haven’t made the news yet.

I was referring to michael adam post

hahaha! Somethings got you worried Sypkan? Not sure what that last rant was about from you? The mistrust of our Govt’s is something that sits high on the radar, I am usually always scrutinising what they say, started with Johnny “I’ve just peed my pants” Howard with the barrage of misinformation and arrogant lies as they passed his thin lips. And it’s just gotten worse from then on. Have you noticed how the LNP leaders talk (more than one of them) and sometimes they’ll let it slip out, they talk like little Johnny who’s just peed in his pants, have you heard hahaha! A total turn off! Yes, of course it is of worthy concern that politicians are untrustworthy, how often do you hear of Politicians rorting the system. From State and Federal, Labor NSW, Libs NSW, Libs Qld, Libs Tas, that I can reflect on.

But this referendum is something for the FNP, look there’s a lot of money put forth to make this event succeed, Yes by the Gov’t, but it’s the right thing to do in so many ways. Cast aside all the other shit and treat this as it is! Do you support the right for Aboriginal First Nations People to have a voice enshrined in the constitution? (Something to that effect) Simple question, you’re a smart guy Sypkan and possibly a bit enraged about something, I don’t know what! But this really matters to the FNP, it really matters! I know it does in so many ways!

sypkan Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 10:37 pm new

people of all colours, shades and persuasions do not trust anything anymore

we are literally in a post truth world...

and the establishment left think they are actually pulling this shit off

and the sole arbiters of truth

when really, people just don't want to vote the miserable fucks on the other side...

despite some pretty gross and gross indiscretions

and that's where lara tingle is right

dutton ain't got a hope in hell

despite his grubby little efforts

he's just as fukn delusional

sypkan Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 10:40 pm new

it's not about me

it's about the electorate

the zietghiest

basesix Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 10:44 pm new

is it?

seeds Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 10:46 pm new

It’s really not that important Syp. You’re sounding as nutty as GSscomo. We be just a bunch of idiots on the third rock. Greet the first rays of the day and enjoy the simple things. I look forward to your first post on the Botany thread!

indo-dreaming Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 10:58 pm new

This shit is getting even weirder and we still have tomorrow to go.

People now want to hold my head under water.

Ideas people are voting No because of Covid or against the government.

And strange ideas that people are voting No to somehow punish FNP.

I will say one thing though, I do think there has been a push back against, big business, sporting bodies, celebrities, musician's, or anyone with a big profile, jumping on the Yes vote and telling us how to vote often in a preachy guilt trip way and then add to that the barrage of TV advertising and other advertising shoved down our throats.

Probably just reinforced soft No's to hard No's though and many undecided to No's .

seeds Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 11:01 pm new

Don’t flatter yourself Indo. Drawn and quartered, maybe.

lostdoggy Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 11:12 pm new

"I will say one thing though, I do think there has been a push back against, big business, sporting bodies, celebrities, musician's, or anyone with a big profile, jumping on the Yes vote and telling us how to vote often in a preachy guilt trip way and then add to that the barrage of TV advertising and other advertising shoved down our throats."

The only push back against famous people saying publicly that they are voting yes is from concrete no voters that were never going to change their mind anyway.

sypkan Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 11:26 pm new

its about trust, plain and simple...

people do not trust the government, big business, ...and the 'captured democracy' that our lobby group driven politics has become...

if you guys cannot see that, I cannot help you

covid and big pharma were the last nail in the coffin, not the beginning...

it may be inconvenient in this eleventh hour, but that's all Im saying

albo and co. rattle on about 'misinformation' ...whilst indulging in it themselves... and being caught out for it... by the abc no less!

using these oh so tired cries of conspiracy theory and misinformation does not win arguments...

it just drags up all the recent history

it isolates, bunkers down, and just shows your an aloof thoughtless twat

albo does twat particularly well...

it's an absolute losing strategy in the current context

labor and yes constantly defaulting to it lost the game

people take offence at being taken for fools... who would've thought?

indo-dreaming Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 11:35 pm new

lostdoggy wrote:

"I will say one thing though, I do think there has been a push back against, big business, sporting bodies, celebrities, musician's, or anyone with a big profile, jumping on the Yes vote and telling us how to vote often in a preachy guilt trip way and then add to that the barrage of TV advertising and other advertising shoved down our throats."

The only push back against famous people saying publicly that they are voting yes is from concrete no voters that were never going to change their mind anyway.

A celebrity saying they are voting Yes is unlikely to turn people off, but a celebrity telling others how to vote i think for many Aussie is a turn off, in the USA it might work but in Australia we have a different culture we dont like that approach.

We are more likely to go fuck you, who you are you tell me how to vote, its same with business and sporting bodies, the AFL were smart they wised up to this and kept the grand final free from it all.

basesix Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 11:46 pm new

indo-dreaming wrote:

This shit is getting even weirder and we still have tomorrow to go.

no, @indo, it is not exciting, it is not a sportgame. people are calm and accepting, as befits something that is foregone now, whatever it is.

I focus Thursday, 12 Oct 2023 at 11:52 pm new

Daming article by Savva... que rants of leftest propaganda.

Niki Savva:
"When Peter Dutton ran for the Liberal leadership in 2018, he twice asked Ken Wyatt to vote for him. Dutton told Wyatt he wanted him on his frontbench. Wyatt told Dutton both times that he would not vote for him. Furthermore, he told him that if he became leader, he would not serve under him, he would quit the ministry.
Beyond expressing concern for the sexual abuse of children, Dutton showed little interest in Indigenous issues, according to Wyatt.
When we spoke a few days ago, Wyatt was as unsurprised as he was unimpressed by Dutton’s conduct of the No campaign in the referendum.
Wyatt dismissed the fevered commentary about Jacinta Nampijinpa Price becoming prime minister. He reckons for a leader to succeed, she – or he – must be capable of, and be seen to be working for, all Australians. He believes neither Dutton nor Price has shown they can do that.
Going down in history as two of the people most responsible for destroying a referendum which Wyatt is convinced would help Indigenous people is no qualification for national leadership in Wyatt’s view.
Born on a mission station to a mother who was forced to hand over her wages to bureaucrats then ask for money back to buy essentials, Wyatt was the first Indigenous person to become Indigenous affairs minister under Scott Morrison. He quit the Liberal Party in protest in April.
Clinging to hope that Yes would triumph, Wyatt worried defeat would deter future governments from considering new approaches. He accepts Anthony Albanese would have no mandate to legislate a Voice but pledged he and fellow Yes warriors would not give up fighting for better ways to address Indigenous disadvantage.
In the post-mortems which will inevitably continue for decades, we can and we will blame No campaigners for playing filthy dirty, for putting politics above everything else, for using loudhailers to whistle up the neo-Nazis, racists and bigots with lies and misrepresentations.
The demons unleashed by tactics to foment conflict, for short term political gain at the expense of vulnerable Australians, will live on long after Saturday’s vote.
We can and will blame the Albanese government for choosing the wrong time or the wrong words or for mismanaging the campaign, for doing it now, or even for doing it at all.
The miserable fact is that no matter the wording, the content, or the timing, we were always destined to get to this point. A few Yes campaigners, including Wyatt, firmly believe this.
There was never going to be bipartisanship. Releasing exposure draft legislation would only have given the Noes more ammunition. Legislating the Voice alone would have once again been whitefellas telling blackfellas what was best for them. Delaying the referendum until the next election would have guaranteed the loss of both the election and the referendum.
Yes advocates say the Noes tapped into a deep well of racism, others that the referendum has created a hell of a mess.
The Noes blame Yes for dividing Australia, which is a bit like claiming black is white. They claim it’s the biggest change to the Constitution ever proposed. Wrong. That was the republic. Their most potent argument against that was if it ain’t broke don’t fix it. Those same people, notably Tony Abbott, know this system is broken, offer no solution and instead seek to destroy the Voice by claiming it will encourage “separatism.”
As if such a modest change to set up an advisory body creates a new apartheid. Confronted by tough questioning, they scream bias. In fact, they have had a good run. Too good.
As the most prominent, the most effective and most polarising participant in the black-on-black conflict, Price has called the shots for the Coalition. She says up front what many of them think but few dare to say. The photo of Price acting as barista in a Perth cafe with Dutton smiling awkwardly behind her like a mobile coffee caddy, says it all.
Not only has she has given white folk an excuse to vote no, she has absolved them of any guilt or shame for past wrongs by insisting colonisation had benefited Aboriginal people. Read David Marr’s excellent book Killing for Country and judge for yourself.
Another of the many low points of this campaign was when the media and others perversely condemned Indigenous leader Marcia Langton for calling out racism, rather than condemn the racism itself. We live in dangerous times when Ray Martin cops more abuse from the Noes for using words like dinosaurs and dickheads than does a neo-Nazi who threatens to kill a senator.
Dutton questioning the integrity of an institution as highly regarded as the Australian Electoral Commission was inexcusable. It opened the door wide for conspiracy theorists to harass and abuse the commission and its staff.
This is a defining moment for Australia. Almost every other country on earth has reached an accommodation with its original inhabitants. We should at least be honest enough to admit that if we don’t, this debate will have simply exposed what lurks just beneath the surface. Blaming Albanese for that is bizarre. Ultimately, responsibility for the result and everything which delivers it resides with us.
The central issue, as it was on the republic, is not what the world thinks of us, as important as that is. It is what we think of each other.
Come Sunday, we will either see ourselves as measured, generous people, ready to set aside the daily woes of our lives – only for a few minutes – to consider the place and state of Indigenous Australians, prepared to say yes to something which will cost us nothing, but could measurably improve their lives.
Or as a frightened, resentful people unable or unwilling to see through the scares and the lies, prepared to use the ballot box to punish the government and in the process punish Indigenous people trapped in cycles of poverty and abuse."

Join the conversation Sign up for free OR Login